Romance Refined
  • Home
  • About
    • Get to know editor Rachel Daven Skinner
    • Portfolio and client testimonials
    • Rachel's industry experience and education
  • Editing
    • Types of editing
    • My editing services and rates
    • Track Changes tutorial
    • Style sheets
    • Example contract
  • Beta Reading
    • Beta reading & sensitivity reading for romance authors
    • Beta reader application
  • Series Bibles
  • Resources
    • Reference books and websites for writers and editors
    • Referrals to other romance industry professionals
    • List of romance conventions and conferences
    • Gift Certificates
  • Contact

Ask a Romantic-Fiction Editor vol. 1

2/27/2014

1 Comment

 
Every now and then I'll post a Q & A culled from a recent interaction I've had with an author. Here's a great one to kick things off:

Question: When one has a good relationship with an editor (i.e. trusts his or her judgment) and is willing to undergo substantive edits, how necessary are beta readers?  If they're still relevant, when would you use them?  Do authors who work with traditional publishers use them?
Answer: Authors who work with traditional publishers do often use beta readers, because even if an author has a signed contract that says they must produce a manuscript, the acquiring editor could still reject the particular manuscript that the author submits, or it could need so much work that it results in the publication date being pushed back. Beta readers are just as important for a self-publishing author, on the grounds that feedback comes from multiple trusted sources--beta readers should be familiar with and like other books that are somewhat similar in genre, and not have any jealous motives that could make them overly critical! When multiple beta readers give similar feedback, it can help the author to work out major kinks thanks to free advice before paying an editor.

I charge a flat rate for my substantive editing, but a lot of editors charge a range or hourly for that service, so if the editor has more work to do, then it would mean paying a higher price for that round of editing. Price aside, the cleaner the manuscript is before an editor starts work, the editor will better be able to hone in on the remaining problem areas without their attention and thought-process being divided between quite as many issues. I do charge a range for my line editing, and a beta reader could improve the writing at that level and thus save an author money there too, but I think beta readers generally have a lesser impact on that level of work, unless they really rock. :) 

Despite all that, though, there are plenty of writers, traditional and self-published, that never have beta readers.
1 Comment
Levi link
2/10/2021 12:16:20 am

Good readding your post

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Looking for editing tips and links to helpful editing resources? Interested in what authors say about the editing process? Curious about books a romance editor reads and reviews* in her spare time? Follow this blog!

    Are you a romance author or editor interested in being interviewed or guest blogging on the theme of editing? Please contact me!

    *I do not accept requests for book reviews. The books I review are from my ginormous personal stockpile.

    All views and info presented on this site are my own, independent of any author or publisher association I may have.

    Categories

    All
    3+ Stars
    4+ Stars
    5 Stars
    Author Interview
    Book Review
    Chick Lit
    Contemporary Romance
    Editing Tips
    Erotic Romance
    Fantasy
    Giveaway
    Historical Romance
    Military Romance
    Mythology
    Paranormal
    Publisher Ballantine Books (Random House)
    Publisher Berkley
    Publisher Berkley Sensation
    Publisher Choc Lit
    Publisher Gallery Books
    Publisher Harlequin
    Publisher Prairie Muse
    Publisher Sourcebooks Casablanca
    Resource Roundup
    Romance
    Romantic Comedy
    Romantic Mystery
    Romantic Suspense
    Self-publishing
    Writing Tips
    YA (Young Adult)

    Archives

    July 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013

    Rachel's bookshelf: currently-reading

    My Sweet Folly
    My Sweet Folly
    by Laura Kinsale
    It
    It
    by Stephen King

    goodreads.com

    2015 Reading Challenge

    2015 Reading Challenge
    Rachel has read 18 books toward her goal of 52 books.
    hide
    18 of 52 (34%)
    view books
    Professional Reader

    quotes Rachel Daven likes


    Goodreads Quotes
Site content and homepage banner image © Rachel Daven Skinner 2013-2017
Book covers used according to fair use policy.
Proudly powered by Weebly